Why Small Business Owners Making Less Than $250K Should Avoid S-Corp Election
Choosing the right business structure is one of the most important decisions for small business owners. While S-corporations (S-corps) are often promoted as a tax-saving strategy, they are not always the best choice, especially for businesses earning less than $250,000 per year. At SRG Advisors LLC, we help entrepreneurs evaluate whether the S-corp election benefits their business.
________________________________________
What Is an S-Corporation?
An S-corp is a tax election that allows business income to pass through to its owners while potentially reducing self-employment taxes. Unlike a sole proprietorship or single-member LLC, S-corps require owners to pay themselves a reasonable salary and comply with strict payroll and IRS rules. While these rules can benefit high-income businesses, they often add unnecessary complexity for smaller operations.
________________________________________Why Small Businesses Under $250K Often Should Avoid an S-Corp
1. Payroll Costs Can Eliminate Tax Savings
When operating as an S-corp, owners must pay themselves a reasonable salary, which triggers payroll taxes, filings, and administrative costs. For businesses earning under $250,000, these expenses often outweigh any potential tax savings.
2. Higher Accounting & Compliance Expenses
Operating an S-corp requires professional bookkeeping, payroll services, and annual corporate filings, which reduces the financial benefit of the S-corp election.
3. Risk of IRS Scrutiny
The IRS closely monitors S-corp salaries. Underpaying yourself to maximize distributions can lead to audits and penalties. For smaller businesses, this risk may not be worth the potential savings.
4. Limited Benefit at Lower Income Levels
Most of the tax advantages of an S-corp, including self-employment tax savings, only become significant when net profits exceed $250,000. Below that threshold, the complexity often outweighs the benefits.
5. Less Flexibility for Expenses
S-corps have stricter rules for health insurance, business deductions, and distributions. A sole proprietorship or single-member LLC allows for simpler management of expenses, health coverage, and deductions, making it easier for small business owners to operate.
________________________________________
When an S-Corp Might Make Sense
S-corp elections are beneficial primarily for businesses with:
• Net profits greater than $250,000
• The ability to separate salary and distributions effectively
• The capacity to handle payroll and compliance requirements
Even then, careful planning is required to avoid audits and penalties from the IRS.
________________________________________
Conclusion
For most small business owners making less than $250,000 per year, a sole proprietorship or single-member LLC is simpler, more flexible, and often just as tax-efficient as an S-corp. S-corps are best suited for higher-income businesses that can absorb the added complexity and cost.
At SRG Advisors LLC, we help business owners choose the right structure for their business based on income, goals, and long-term growth plans. Making the right choice now can save headaches and money down the road.